Context is key
by Stephen Peirce
One of the most pleasing aspects of the surge of interest in family history and genealogy is that is has put historical research and learning to the forefront of the minds of people who otherwise might have said they had no interest in history.
One of the greatest challenges facing those teaching history as a subject, be it at primary, secondary or, to a lesser extent, third level, has been maintaining the engagement of their students. The great thing about genealogy and family history are that they tend to be personal and when something is personal or relatable we tend to be more likely to engage with it.
However, there is a flip-side to this, in that there are now many people engaging in genealogy and family history, who lack a historical context for the time periods in which they are researching.
Context can mean everything. It can explain why a couple had three children in four years between 1910-14 and then none until another three in quick succession in 1919-24 (World War I 1914-18). It may also offer a pointer as to why your ancestors left Ireland circa 1850 (Height of the Great Famine 1845-52). Or even answer why so many members of a family died in 1918-20 (Spanish Flu pandemic)
The above examples are extremes, but much more localised events can have similar impacts; the clearance of tenants on estates, localised famines and food shortages, natural disasters, etc. Knowing the history of the places your ancestors lived and the times they lived through, can provide vital clues to research. Equally for emigrant ancestors what was happening in their ‘new world’, was the emigration push or pull? Were your ancestors ‘convicts’ or colonisers?
Studying secondary literature can really help to explain the actions of your ancestors or offer clues for further research. And remember, that’s no exam at the end, the only result that matters is you gaining a better understanding of the lives your ancestors led.
By Paul Manzor
Comments
Excellent tip!
I was a History major in college and that background helps me when I look at DNA results. In my own case, my ancestry traces back to Ireland, the birthplace of seven of my Great Grandparents (the eighth was born in England). However my ethnicity results, or Haplogroup, shows a predominance of Scandinavian heritage, with a small bit of French/German and Spanish in the mix. If I wasn't aware of the Viking excursions into the British Isles & Ireland, the Norman invasions, and the Spanish Armada's defeat by the British Navy, when Spanish sailors were often washed ashore along the Irish coast, I might think I was adopted!! Eileen Miller
Nice tip. Any tips on finding those secondary sources? One could scour the local papers for daily or weekly stories, but that seems a bit inefficient. On the other hand, history books are a touch general & don't address local issues. Any specific ideas? Dan Mayclin, [email protected]@ebold.com
Topics